Get in touch

Leadership & Decision Making

Blockbuster failure: the cognitive bias every manager should know

By Enrico Giubertoni

Trusted by

  • Worldline
  • Alba Leasing
  • L'Erbolario
  • 3M
The closing page of the Blockbuster Italia website: «Thank you all. The adventure of Blockbuster Italia ends here»
The screen with which Blockbuster Italia said goodbye to its customers.

Do you remember walking into a Blockbuster shop? For years that ritual defined home entertainment: you chose a film on the shelves, rented the cassette or the DVD and brought it back a few days later. The Blockbuster failure is a textbook case of strategic analysis, and its true cause is a cognitive bias, that is a systematic error of judgement, in the people who read the data. The chain of video rental shops filed for Chapter 11 (the US procedure that protects a company from its creditors while it tries to restructure) in 2010 (source: Todd Davis and John Higgins, A Blockbuster Failure: How an Outdated Business Model Destroyed a Giant, University of Tennessee College of Law, 2013), and Blockbuster Italia followed the same rapid destiny.

As happened to Kodak, the axe of digital Darwinism also fell on Blockbuster.

Digital Darwinism is the common explanation: companies that fail to adapt to digital technology disappear. If you are a marketing decision maker, you need to go beyond that surface story. The data of Blockbuster told the truth. The error was in how the management read them, and that error can happen in any company, today too.

Members area Coming soon

Free tools for your work: your result in two minutes

Calculators for marketing, sales, HR and R&D. Leave your email and we will tell you when it opens.

We write to you once, when the area opens. The numbers you enter in the tools are anonymous and are not stored on our servers.

Thank you. We will write to you once, when the area is live.

The data told the truth, the interpretation was fatal

The management of Blockbuster had accurate data in its hands: surveys and statistics that confirmed, without any doubt, that customers appreciated the experience in the shop. They loved walking between the shelves, choosing the cover with their own hands, talking with the staff.

Those data were correct. They were a perfect photograph of that specific reality, at that precise moment in history. The catastrophic problem was the interpretation distorted by bias. The decision makers, already deeply invested in the business model of physical shops, read in those numbers the proof that their leadership could not be attacked and that digital was a marginal threat.

Confirmation bias behind the Blockbuster failure

Here the most classic of cognitive biases appears: confirmation bias, the tendency to look for and to value only the information that confirms what we already believe. The managers looked in the data for the evidence that confirmed their vision of the world, namely that the physical experience was irreplaceable, and they found it. In the same process they ignored or reduced all the weak signals that contradicted this thesis: late fees, the disappointment of a film out of stock, the inconvenience of the double trip to the shop. The same mechanism in competitive analysis is described in the article on competitive strategy and cognitive bias.

This selective blindness, fed by bias, produced the most fatal consequence: the strategic decision to keep digital at a distance, treating it as a passing fashion instead of an imminent revolution. The management chose to stop innovating because its preconceptions were stronger than the evidence. I call this condition Strategic Blindness: a management that sees the data and stops seeing the market.

The Long Tail: the market that exploits the bias of others

While the leadership of Blockbuster refused to see the future, the market kept moving.

The model of the Long Tail, described by Chris Anderson, showed how digital could make an almost infinite offer of niche products economically sustainable. A physical shop has limited shelves and has to fill them with the titles that sell most; a digital catalogue has no shelf, so the sum of thousands of small titles can be worth as much as the few big hits. The theory is explained in detail in the article on the Long Tail theory.

The Blockbuster shops in Italy and in the rest of the world were built on scarcity and on big hits. The same lever of scarcity supports flash sales today, which use it for a few hours and not as a business model. Netflix built its offer on the exact opposite: abundance and personalisation. It occupied the space left empty by the cognitive bias of Blockbuster, and answered the needs of convenience and variety that the old management refused to see. The closed website of Blockbuster Italia is the monument to this strategic blindness. It is the risk that Paul Arden describes in a book that teaches to think the opposite of what everybody thinks: when a whole management shares the same certainty, nobody tests it any more.

Strategic lessons: how to overcome your own cognitive bias

The case of Blockbuster is a powerful warning, and for this reason it is one of the examples I use in the executive training of my individual coaching programmes for managers and decision makers. The company failed because of rigid thinking, and the technology only revealed it. For a modern manager the lessons are three:

  1. Be aware of your biases. The first step is to admit having them: confirmation bias, resistance to change and inertia toward the status quo, excessive confidence in past successes. Recognising them is the only way to reduce their effect.
  2. Look actively for contrary evidence. Go beyond the data that confirm your strategy. Create a process to find the weak points, the criticism, the divergent opinions. Ask a member of your team to play the devil’s advocate, that is the person whose task is to argue against the decision.
  3. Distinguish a habit from a preference. Do your customers behave in a certain way because they really prefer it, or because they still have no better alternative? Learn to read between the lines of their behaviour.

The end of Blockbuster teaches that the greatest risk for a company is rarely the new competitor you fail to see coming. It is the prejudice that prevents you from understanding the world that changes in front of your eyes.

Frequently asked questions

Why did Blockbuster fail?

The cause was a cognitive bias, more than the data or a technology. The management had accurate data on how much customers liked the experience in the shop, read them as proof that its leadership could not be attacked, and decided to keep digital at a distance, treating it as a passing fashion instead of an imminent revolution.

How did confirmation bias affect the managers of Blockbuster?

Confirmation bias pushes people to look in the data only for the evidence that confirms their own vision. The managers of Blockbuster found confirmation that the physical experience was irreplaceable and ignored the weak signals that said the opposite: late fees, the disappointment of a film out of stock, the inconvenience of the double trip to the shop.

How did Netflix take advantage of the errors of Blockbuster?

Blockbuster was built on scarcity and on big hits. Netflix bet on the opposite, abundance and personalisation, following the Long Tail model of Chris Anderson, which makes an almost infinite offer of niche products economically sustainable. In this way Netflix occupied the space left empty by the bias of Blockbuster, and answered the needs of convenience and variety.

How can a manager overcome their own cognitive biases?

The first step is to admit having them: confirmation bias, inertia toward the status quo, excessive confidence in past successes. Then comes the search for contrary evidence.

Enrico Giubertoni

Enrico Giubertoni

Performance Systems Architect™

Enrico Giubertoni is a revenue systems designer, management consultant and keynote speaker.

Read more

As a Performance Systems Architect™, since 1998 he has been decoding digital signals for revenue governance and Signal Intelligence™ (reading latent buying signals) in B2B companies. His work identifies Analytical Inertia (the data a company owns but does not turn into decisions) within business units and turns it into Financial Velocity, the speed at which a company generates value.

He is the author of five publications on digital marketing and more than 360 articles, and since 2006 he has run one of the longest-running strategy blogs in Europe.

Source transparency: report an error

What are your business challenges?

Tell me about your priorities and the goals you want to reach.
Enrico Giubertoni will give you targeted feedback within one business day.